Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm felt like a no-brainer swap. Plus, at the time the limited edition Birthday Cake scent—which just so happened to be the prettiest pale pink hue—had just come out.

When broken down, Summer Friday's balm comes to $48 an ounce, and Trader Joe's balm is about $6.73.

Beauty brand Summer Fridays teased the launch of four new ... lobbied for the return of the brand’s bestselling Birthday Cake lip balm. The Bare Sand, Rose Bud, Midnight Berry, and Warm Beige ...