Babies with colic are notoriously difficult to soothe, so we love that the Bibs “Try-It” Collection allows you to test-drive different pacifier styles to see which one your fussy baby likes best.

Rexann resorted to giving the infant a pacifier. "We sort of hoped she would be a thumbsucker and comfort herself," says Brew, of Pasadena, Calif., who admits she and her husband awoke at least ...